Delaware County, Indiana
Settled 1822
While conducting field research on my Liberty Township ancestor, Martin Shively, I visited Smithfield and the surrounding cemeteries. Martin Shively was a common man that moved his family in the 1840s into Delaware County from Richland County, Ohio. The 1850 census showed that he and his family lived just north of Smithfield as a laborer probably on the John Richardson farm. On the 1860 census, he was living next to or on John Friedline’s farm. Martin's son, Isaac Shively , lived next to Eliza Hutchings just east of Smithfield. No records have been found to show where Martin is buried but my bet is in an unmarked grave in the Friedline Cemetery among other related family members. (Checkout the Friedline Cemetery webpage.
In order to understand and to try to uncover more about my ancestors, I selected Smithfield because it was the first Indiana location that my family settled and it was a somewhat unpublished and quaint village steeped in early Hoosier history. I collected as much data as I could during three different field trips to that area. Recently I decided (10+ years after the field trips) to put all the copies, notes and recollections that I had gathered together onto a webpage to assist other genealogists and Indiana historians on what I had found on Smithfield.
I retyped all the names from census data and plat maps in an attempt to make the webpage “search engine friendly” so you could find your ancestors easier – I hope that it has worked for you.
With any webpage or researched data errors can happen and facts can be mistaken. If you have any
corrections, additions, photos or personal stories about Smithfield you are willing to share, please send me an email and I
will be glad to include them.
Happy hunting!
Scot Shively
Family genealogist and amateur historian
Smithfield is the oldest town or village in Liberty Township and in fact is one of the oldest settlements in Delaware County. Over 180 years ago pioneers recognized the area as just what they were looking for. It is pleasantly situated on a level upland overlooking White River, which meanders among shady woods and fertile fields.
The first settlements in Liberty Township were made, as is usually the case, along the water courses. In this case there were three land entries made in the township in 1822, all three being in sections 21 and 28, in the neighborhood of White River, just below the old town of Smithfield. The first of these entries was made by James Jackson, November 11, 1822.
Smithfield was the name was given to a small collection of houses which stood there long before
the town was surveyed and laid out into town lots by the original proprietors, David Stout and William Duncan.
Early Indiana pioneer cabins were built of round logs from eight to ten inches through, and covered with clapboards. They were of all sizes; some perhaps of twelve by fourteen feet, and some eighteen by twenty five feet, with one seven or eight feet story and a loft above in the roof. A small cabin would have one door and one window. Cabins in Delaware County probably looked like the cabin in this photo which was built in the 1830s in Greene County, Indiana.
An early Indiana pioneer, David Stout, settled at Smithfield in 1828. Finding the White River suitable he erected the first mill in the township, Stout’s Mill. At about the same time John G. Deeds settled at the same point and erected the second mill called “Deed’s Mill.”
Daniel Stout had been County Commissioner in Randolph,
and had moved to what is now
Delaware County, built a mill and laid out Smithfield, I presume he had that county erected
into Liberty Township. There were but few inhabitants in that region, and David Rowe, who
brought the election returns, lived pretty well up on Prairie Creek, at least six miles from
Smithfield. Also, May, 1826, John J. Deeds, who had settled on White River and built a mill
above Smithfield, was appointed Supervisor on the West Fork of White River from the mouth of
Cabin Creek to Mont-see-town, as the Indians called it. Hence “Mont-see-town” was then (May, 1826)
in Liberty Township was still a part of Randolph County.
History of Randolph County
Mills
Mills were often the place where farmers would gather with
their sacks of grain and exchange news with distance neighbors. In early Indiana, it was not
unusual to travel twenty miles to reach the mill. Smithfield’s two mills served the inhabitants
of the town and the farmers living throughout Liberty Township
Stout’s Mill built in the early ‘30s was located just west of Smithfield and is depicted on the 1874 and 1887 atlas maps (coordinates: 40°10’10.44N, 85°16’11.65” W).
Deed’s Mill was described as being “above” Smithfield. Studying the 1874 Delaware County map you can see another millrace located just northwest of the center of town approximately 1,500ft. This location matches the described location of Deed’s Mill (coordinates: 40°10’16.75N, 85°16’19.88” W).
Because of the topography of the land where the 2 mill races were located was flat I would guess the two mills’ operated with an undershot wheel.
Other early settlers along the banks of White River near Smithfield (section 22) were:
Today, Smithfield lies about 6 miles southeast of Muncie at the intersection
of East County Road 625 East and East County Road 167 South (Smithfield Pike)
along the East bank of the White River.
Smithfield is one of those quiet hamlets so often seen at this age, which have relapsed from a more favorable condition; for this was once a point of some consequence, well known to emigrants of earlier days. Its merchants had a good trade, as had also its blacksmiths and other mechanics. But time diverted its trade to other centers, and it became the quiet village that we see to-day.
At the present, its mercantile interests are represented by one store, kept by J. K. Norris; Daniel Williams is the village blacksmith, and William Miller is the proprietor of a flouring-mill, situated on the bank of White River, its machinery being propelled by power from that stream.
History of Delaware County T. B. Helm 1881
Merchants
We think the first merchant in Liberty Township was Jeremiah Fenner. He
was located at Smithfield in the general merchandising way at an early date, and
after four or five years sold his stock and good will to a Mr. Garrison.
Thomas Leonard opened a store here a few years later and remained in the village until his death, then William Lewis engaged in business at the stand. Mr. Lewis afterwards sold goods in the new town of Selma.
1846 (Directory)
Thomas Leonard & Co – mercantile in Smithfield
1874 (Atlas)
Duncan & Norris (located on the corner of Main and Liberty Street, Lot 4 of Block 4)
Goods, Groceries, Ready Made Clothing, Hats, Caps, Boots, shoes, Notions, etc.
Miller, Wm Proprietor Smithfield Grist Mill (formally “Deed’s Mill”)
Dealer in all Kinds Produce
Williams & Cannady, Manufacturers of Wagons & Buggies (along Market St, Lot 2 of Block 2)
Doing General Custom Work
1881 (History of Delaware Co.)
J. K. Norris - mercantile store
Daniel Williams – village blacksmith
William Miller – proprietor of the flour mill (originally Stout’s Mill then called the Smithfield Mill)
1887 (Atlas)
Flour Mill (located on Jacob Miller’s land, probably still named Smithfield Mill)
Cane Mill (located on the corner of Market and Liberty Street, Lot 1 of Block 2)
Physicians
Dr. Jeremiah Dynes was the physician for the people of Smithfield and the surrounding area. He appeared
in the 1850 census and was born about 1819 in Ohio and married Caroline (born in Indiana about 1822).
They raised their family in Liberty Township and were substantial land owners (property value of $3,000 - 1850 census).
There was also a Dr. Isaac Redout in the 1850 census (born in Maine about 1802), married to Sarah. They lived about a mile north of Smithfield.
Smithfield Cemetery
There is very little information available on this small graveyard at the east end of Market
Street. (Block 1, Lot 1). From the earliest recorded burial the cemetery was being used as
early as May 1847. Perhaps, because it is lot 1 in block 1 of the town, the original proprietors,
David Stout and William Duncan, set it aside as a cemetery when they laid out the town around 1829-30.
The cemetery appears on the 1873 tax assessor’s survey and the 1887 Delaware Co. Atlas.
Recorded burials include:
| Davis, James F. | died Feb 2 1854 | aged 97y 9m 29d | |
| Dunkin, William P. | died Aug 22 1849 | age 9m 8d | Son of ? and H. Dunkin |
| Irvin, Charlotte | died May 27 1847 | age 6y 11m 22d | |
| Irvin, William | died Jan 9 1853 | age 55y | |
| McCall, Orren | died Dec 21 1862 | age 2y 6m 12 d | Son of J & C McCall |
Smithfield 1887 Structures – Total of 24 depicted on survey
Block 1
3 buildings
Block 2
6 buildings, Cane Mill, School No. 8 and adjacent flour Mill
Block 3
2 buildings
Block 4
1 building (M. E. Church)
Block 5
7 buildings
Other adjacent parcels
5 buildings
School Houses
Early Indiana pioneer school houses were small log houses, not to exceed twenty
feet square, though many were built later about twenty-six feet by thirty feet. They
were covered with clapboards and had oiled-paper windows. A huge fireplace was built
at one side or one end of the building which enabled the children to keep warm on the
side next to the fire. All had puncheon floors; that is, floors made of slabs or logs split
or hewn instead of being sawed. The seats were made of split saplings or mill slabs from
twelve to fifteen feet in length. Usually seats were placed on either side and extended
back from the fireplace. Another was placed across the front of the fireplace. To the rear
of these seats a table, possibly three feet wide and twelve or fifteen feet long, extended
across the room, and on either side of the table were placed split pole or mill slab seats,
each of the length of the table. At this table or desk the children faced each other and were
enabled to work with some degree of comfort. Those occupying the other seats had to hold
their slates and books on their laps. Frequently, and in fact very commonly, another desk
was made along one or two sides of the house by driving pegs into the logs and laying a
wide board on them. This was called the "writing desk." In some of the very early school
houses there were no blackboards at all. In others a wide board was hung on pegs driven
into the logs. In many buildings there were two additional pegs driven into the wall near
or over the teacher's desk.
During the summer of 1835 James A. Maddy taught school at Smithfield. The log schools were retained until about the time of the Civil War or a little later, when they were replaced by frame buildings. Later the brick school houses replaced the frame buildings and were built throughout the county in 1879. School house number 8 was built on Lot 6 of Block 2 (on E. L. D. Storm’s lot – 1873 tax assessor’s survey) in Smithfield.
Smithfield Schoolhouse Today (photo courtesy of Cheryl Cross)
Currently a private residence.
Miscellaneous People Sightings
The Methodist Episcopal Church of Smithfield
Perhaps the frame building was located at Lot 7 of Block 5, near the intersection of Liberty and
Market Streets. (as recorded in the land record book)
Worship in private houses continued for a period of three or four years when Thomas and Samuel Leonard
sold Smithfield Lot #7 in Block 4 to the congregation to build their new church.
The new Smithfield church was destroyed by fire, and a new one was built, even before Selma
became a town (in the early 1850s).
Prosperity had come into the community in about 1903 with the discovery of oil as well
as gas. Wells were being drilled in many places. It is said that the cause of the fire that
destroyed the Smithfield Church, August 20, 1904, was fire which was ignited in the reservoir
tank under the eaves of the Church. The oil well was just to the rear of the Church.
In 1905, the Church felt itself strong enough to launch into a larger program of expansion
and influence and replaced the church at a cost of $4,700. In 1913 just seven years after
building the new Smithfield Church it was now longer an active congregation.
In the trend toward the modern way of life it often happens that churches which are located
in the open country or in easy access to the towns or cities are closed. It is often unfortunate.
With Selma growing as a town along the railroad many of the members elected to transfer to
the Selma Church. The falling away of members in the Smithfield congregation was so gradual that
little can be noted of the decease in its relation to the Selma Charge.
However, when the relatively new Church was sold in Smithfield in 1953, the proceeds of the sale
were applied to the Church in Selma. The bell which hung in the Church at Smithfield was removed
and placed in the Selma Church steeple. The Selma Church bell was placed in the inactive Church at
Smithfield. Later the organ from Smithfield was also moved to the Selma church.
It stands as a tragedy that so fine a Church structure should be sold to a private individual
for only $460. After still another transfer, it was sold to a branch of the Church of God, who now
held services in the birthplace of Methodism in Liberty Township.
Smithfield Bridge
Current photo of the old iron Smithfield bridge (photo courtesy of Cheryl Cross)
Smithfield Oil Field (photo courtesy of Tom McKee)
Roads
East (Smithfield to Windsor)
South (Smithfield - Burlington Pike)
West (Smithfield – Muncie Pike)
Railroad
The double tracked Ohio gauge main line ran eastward from Ingalls through Pendleton, Anderson, and
Chesterfield on its way to Muncie and Union City on the Indiana Ohio border. From Muncie to Union
City was a 32 mile stretch. Here, it connected with the Dayton and Union tracks and linked Indianapolis
via Muncie to the railways in the East.
Smithfield was laid out in 1828, grew and prospered for the next 22 years, (until 1850) as a pioneer
town due mainly to the influx of settlers. Smithfield’s location, being conveniently nestled along the
banks of White River, was established and by 1840 a trading point along one of the first few roads of in
the area, the Smithfield to Albany Pike.
Track construction began from Indianapolis toward Muncie with the goal of ending at the Indiana-Ohio
state line. The construction of the railroad was undoubtedly a huge event for the inhabitants of
Smithfield and Liberty Township. Construction of the railroad tracks reached Muncie by the summer of
1852 and was probably north of Smithfield by the fall. No doubt some of the local citizens and farmers
ventured out to the construction site to watch the project under way.
Finally on 20 January 1853 the Indiana tracks were tied together with the Ohio tracks at
the new town of Union. Monday, the 24th of January 1853, marked the day the railroad line was
officially open for the first through passenger train from Dayton via Union City onto Indianapolis.
The new railroad tracks, being laid across the township and passing about a mile north of
town, sounded the death-knell of Smithfield. Although there was quite a business done for several
years thereafter, the new town of Selma sprang up along the tracks. Smithfield began to deteriorate
and business gradually left for Selma which prospered. Smithfield continued to diminish until it had
become more valuable for cornfields than as a town or trading point.
Indian Mound (1874 Atlas)
Smithfield Town Lot Owners – 1873 Tax Assessor’s Survey (see map)
Delinquent Taxpayers, Liberty Twp (Smithfield) – 1847
Those for Liberty Township (Smithfield) included:
Liberty Township – Delaware County 1830 Census
Coordinates of mentioned places
References
Lot transfer to the M.E. Church - Land Record Book at Delaware Co., Courthouse
Samuel Leonard to Smithfield M.E. Church 1 Sep 18xx (unreadable, looks like 1850s)
Lot 7 Sq 5 $1 Bk 11, Pg 402
Thomas Leonard to Smithfield M.E. Church Lot 7 Sq 5 $15 Book unknown
There have been no dates found that state when the first bridge over the White River was
built, however the bridge is drawn on the 1874 Atlas of Delaware County. As was the method
in the early years, the original bridge was most likely constructed of wood and replaced a few times.
The current 190’ long iron bridge that crosses the White River is a through truss design built in 1902.
North (Smithfield – Albany Pike)
One of the first roads opened for public travel in Delaware County was from Deed's Mill at
Smithfield to the village of Albany. This road ran parallel with, and one mile west, of the county
line. It was opened in 1833, as it was a new road, and greatly obstructed by trees and underbrush
when Reuben Strong same to the township, in 1834. He was compelled to cut his way over a portion of
the route. The road was both ill shaped and ill kept until it was formally surveyed, straightened,
and improved generally, in 1840. It traverses the township in a north and south line, forming the
western boundary of Sections 12, 13, 24 and 25.
Another early laid-out road was the one from Windsor, through Smithfield, to Muncie. It was
surveyed and located at the expense of Randolph County, on the south side of White River. From
this road another branched off near the Parker Truitt farm, running in a northwesterly course to the
town of Granville.
The Smithfield and Burlington Pike runs from Smithfield in a southerly course, to New Burlington,
in Perry Township. This route crossed the White River over the Smithville Bridge at the west edge of the town.
The road from Muncie to Marion, Ind., was laid out soon after the early settlement of the
township began, and from time to time, as occasion required, roads were located from one point to
another within the township, to facilitate local travel and communication. In later years several
of the principal roads were converted into turnpikes which have proved of great benefit in seasons
when the other roads have been almost impassable.
The Muncie, Smithfield, and Windsor Turnpike Company was established in 1868. The original members included John Cline and John Cecil. In 1868-9 Israel and Eliza Hutchings had a right of way complaint which was resolved within the year.
(Muncie, Smithfield and Windsor Turnpike Company Records, Indiana State Library)
In 1847-48, the Indiana State Legislature approved a charter for a new railroad line to
connect Indianapolis to the railroads in Ohio. The “Bee Line”, as it was known, was officially
the Indianapolis and Bellefontaine line and would become the first railroad to connect Indiana
to the East and only the second line to connect Indianapolis.
“One mile west of Selma is a lake or peat bog now partially filled up, which with the
drainage, has converted the waste into wheat and corn land. When the Bee Line railroad first built
their embankment across this, they returned one morning to find the results of their labors swallowed
up in the depths of the treacherous bog, the accumulated mass of vegetation which had given away,
precipitating the mass into the waters beneath. This point required constant watching and repairs
for year . . .” according to A. J. Phinney in the 1881 state geology report.
Robert Milnor, Chief Engineer, 1852.
Elihu Cecil Mound (Liberty Township, Section 23). A mound 30 feet in diameter and 30 inches high
is located on the North bank of the White River. May still exist. Had been trenched by local
collectors prior to 1930.
Daniel William - 2 acres (northeast in town)
Jessy Knorris – 94/100 (northeast in town)
Block 1
Lot 1 – Grave Yard
Lot 2 – Andrew Knoff
Lot 3 – Andre Knoff
Lot 4 – Andrew Knoff
Lot 5 – George Cannady
Lot 6 – George Cannady
Lot 7 – Henry Will
Lot 8 – Lovina
Block 2
Lot 1 – John F. Dynes
Lot 2 – Daniel Williams
Lot 3 – Eliza Hutchings
Lot 4 – Margaret Will
Lot 5 – Benjamin W. Bush
Lot 6 – E. L. D. Storms
Block 3
Lot 1 – Henry Will
Lot 2 – Henry Will
Lot 3 – Eliza Hutchings
Lot 4 – Will Hill
Lot 5 – Will Hill
Lot 6 – Will Hill
Block 4
Lot 1 – Catharine Vickroy (sp ?)
Lot 2 – Henry Will
Lot 3 – Henry Will
Lot 4 – Henry Will
Lot 5 – M. E. Church (north half)
Lot 5 – Henry Will (south half)
Lot 6 – M. E. Church (north half)
Lot 6 – Henry Will (south half)
Lot 7 – Henry Will
Lot 8 – Catharine Vickroy (sp ?)
Block 5
Lot 1 – John F. Dynes (north half)
Lot 1- Charles Daugherty (south half)
Lot 2 – John F. Dynes (north half)
Lot 2 – Charles Daugherty (south half)
Lot 3 – Ruben Pence (north half)
Lot 3 – Joseph Davis (south half)
Lot 4 – Ruben Pence (north half)
Lot 4 – Joseph Davis (south half)
Lot 5 – Robert Hadley
Lot 6 – Robert Hadley
Lot 7 – Caroline Dynes
Lot 8 – John W. Bush
The “Indiana” Signal” (Dec 13, 1848) contained a list of lands and lots in Delaware Co.
returned delinquent for nonpayment of taxes for the year 1847. Some landowners held land in
more than one township. The auditor gave notice that the lands and lots would be sold at public
auction to pay for the taxes, interest and penalties owed. The sale would he held on the first
Monday, being the first day of January, 1849. Those not sold would be forfeited to the state.
William Broderick
Joseph Brandon
Eli Babb, Jr.
Samuel Cecil
Thomas Clevenger
Thomas Cline
Peter Clark
Benjamin Cunkle
Peter Cline
Thomas Cox
Samuel Coy
Benjamin Garreston
Jackson Holmes
David Mamer
Adam Keever
Lewis Kendall
William Phillips
Martin Sweetman
Bevans Turner
Cornelius Vanausdoll
Bannell, Willen C.
Earow, William
James, Elizabeth
Spencer, Ahamond
Barris, Daniel
Eastey, Philip
Johnson, Solomon
Stansberry, William
Biggs, Joel
Eastley, William
Jones, Hepher
Stewart, Zedak
Blalock, Maredy
Edwards, Absolom
Kahn, Peter
Stout, David
Bolton, Henry
Elbor, Aaron
Kegin, Rush
Tagart, Samuel
Bottimore, William
Ellison, Andrew
Kenard, Francis
Taylor, Henry
Boyler, John
Evans, Jefferson
Kenard, William
Taylor, James
Bransome, Jacob
Fletcher, William
Kenneday, Andrew
Teples, Robert
Branson, Malen
Gibson, Boweter
Keyin, Richard
Thompson, Henry
Brock, Sherad
Gibson, Robert
King, Johnson
Thornbough, Joseph
Brosbey, Levi
Gibson, Valentine
Kuhn, Francis
Thornbourgh, Azel
Brown, David
Gibson, William
Kuhn, John
Thornbourgh, Richard
Brown, William
Ginn, John
Les, Alfred
Thornbourgh, Thomas
Casteel, Elijah
Gobb, Robert
Livingston, Margareth
Thornbourgh, Thomas, Sr
Clevage, Thomas
Harbuck, Pristan
Macomb, Samuel
Thornbourgh, William
Cline, Henry
Hartin, David C.
Martin, Isaac
Thornbourgh, William L.
Collins, Elijah
Harvey, Beanshamp
Mc Alister, Ezekiel
Towers, William
Collison, John
Haway, Samuel
Mc Millen, Junior
Truett, Parker
Connor, Briton
Hessenflow, Joseph
Mc Miller, Junior
Turner, George
Connor, John
Hill, John
Moore, John, Sr.
Turner, Jonathan
Cooper, Benjamin
Hobough, Solomon
Patter, Wilder
Turner, Joseph
Crawford, Thomas
Hobough, Solomon
Poff, George
Underhill, William
Davis, James
Hodson, Elizabeth
Poff, Henry
Vanassedall, Cornelius
Davis, Richard
Hodson, Moses
Poffer, Samuel
Wair, William
Deanmiry, Benjamin
Hoover, Martin
Rees, Lewis
Walker, Benjamin
Deed, George
Howell, John
Reese, John
West, Aquila
Deeds, John G.
Hump, Leonard
Richardson, Aaron
West, James
Delano, Jesse
Hunt, Uriah
Roe, David
West, Jonathan
Dewitt, Daniel
Jackson, Amar
Rose, Daniel
Williams, Samuel
Dilly, John
Jackson, Hiram
Scott, David
Williams, William
Dimmist, Thomas
Jackson, Isaac
Shoemaker, Jorael
Williams, William, Sr.
Downing, Washington
Jackson, James
Simmonds, Peter
Downing, William
Jackson, James
Simmons, Samuel
Duncan, William
Jackson, John
Smith, John
Smithfield
40°10’11.37N
85°16’08.15” W
Stout’s Mill
40°10’10.44N
85°16’11.65” W
Deed’s Mill
40°10’16.75N
85°16’19.88” W
Smithfield Bridge
40°10’7.60N
85°16’15.87” W
Smithfield Cemetery
40°10’10.92N
85°16'02.28” W
Smithfield M.E. Church
40°10’05.40N
85°16'05.06” W
FriedlineCemetery
40°09’05.40N
85°14'19.15” W
Helm, Thomas B. History Of Delaware County Indiana 1881
Hesser, Leon F. The Taming of the Wilderness Indiana’s transition from Indian hunting grounds to Hoosier
Farmland: 1800-1875 e-book, 2002.
Kingman, A. L. “Map of Delaware County Indiana” 1874.
Map of the Bellefontaine and Indiana Railroad and Connecting Lines, Robert Milnor, Chief Engineer, 1852.
Sieber, Ellen and Munson, Cheryl Ann, Looking at History, Indiana University Press, 1992.
Tucker E., History of Randolph County Indiana, Chicago: A. L. Kingman, 1882.
Turner, Samuel “Indiana Register and Pocket Manual” Indianapolis, 1846, pp 100-101.
Richman, George J. History of Hancock County, Indiana, 1916.
copyright 2006 Scot Shively
Webmaster Beth Shively
last update 7 Feb 2010
since 25 Mar 08